Anti-anti-Islamism in the West: Cold War apologists for communism in new clothing
Saturday, November 13th, 2010There’s a super piece of writing in the current edition of the Weekly Standard by Lee Smith, one of the magazine’s senior editors. His piece concerns the phenomenon of what he calls anti-anti-Islamism, the practice by many in the liberal establishment of alleging that concerns about Islamism are either overblown or, worse, represent a deliberate subterfuge designed as a cover for the West’s warlike ambitions and a means of distracting attention from the “real issues” of Western imperialism and exploitation.
As Smith notes, we have been here before. During the Cold War legions of “intellectuals” and academics adopted precisely such a posture against opponents of communism. In most cases, it wasn’t that they were fully paid up communist ideologues themselves — though there were plenty of such people in the early years of communist rule. Rather, they were just more opposed to the societies they lived in than they were to the totalitarian alternative offered by communism. Acting on the principle that my enemy’s enemy is my friend, they sought to downplay or excuse communist tyranny and frequently to argue, when faced with evidence of it they could not refute, that in so far as there were problems in communist countries they were largely a response to western “aggression” and would only get worse if that aggression continued.
Smith illustrates his point with a vignette about the abominable Cat Stevens and his appearance at comedian and political commentator Jon Stewart’s recent “Rally to Restore Sanity” in Washington DC:
Now, let’s be clear about a couple of things right from the beginning: First, all other things being equal a liberal-democratic society should have no problem accommodating a multiplicity of different cultures, and the traditions and customs that go with them; Second, in a free society, again with that proviso — all other things being equal — the way people dress in particular should be entirely their affair. As general propositions about Western society, few would disagree.